Information-Driven Business
Robert Hillard

Metadata versus Taxonomy
by Robert Hillard

I’ve advocated for many years that Information Management should be a superset of related disciplines including data warehousing, document management, library science, enterprise search et cetera.  While this is an easy statement to make, it is really hard to execute.

The problem is that practitioners from the different technical backgrounds have radically different approaches to handling information in all of its forms.  While the technologies are different (using solutions as diverse as relational databases, file systems and even physical shelving) this is not the real reason why the disciplines are so hard to bring together.

Practitioners coming from unstructured and structured data backgrounds use subtly different definitions of metadata and I argue that it is these differences that cause most of the angst that comes through in disparate repositories, governance and a lack of integrated business solutions.

Unstructured data came first, and its filing is primarily treated as a problem of taxonomy.  The most famous approach is, of course, the Dewey Decimal System.  When unstructured data practitioners talk of metadata they include the taxonomy and attributes of the data itself such as the author, publication date, copyright and other core attributes (best defined by Dublin Core).

Structured data practitioners have, for the past forty years, relied on relational database theory as the foundation of their information management practices.  Relational data generally includes as data, rather than definition, the key elements of people, place and time.  Such an approach is very neat, with metadata being literally data about data and being restricted to data structures and the definition of the data elements themselves.  As a result, the metadata for structured data is much more succinct.

While succinct is a good thing for computer programmers, it seldom translates well for the rest of society.  As a result, structured database metadata has seldom found its way out of technical departments within large organisations.  At the same time, the need to understand who authored a record, who it was about and how it relates to other events in a timeline remain as important as ever.  As a result, we now have “master data”.

Perhaps the solution is for all Information Management practitioners to concede that Metadata should encompass both the metadata that structured data practitioners advocate and the master data that the unstructured data practitioners have long advocated as being essential.  We just have to get over our fixation on the titles.  I’ve tried to define an approach that does this in my new book, Information-Driven Business.

comments powered by Disqus

blogThe Information-Driven Business blog is published monthly:

   2019   2018   2017   2016   2015
   2014   2013   2012   2011   2010

Also featured from the Information-Driven Business blog:

Exponential answers or fake news
“Exponential” is one of those great words loved by the start-up community and technology investors alike. Exponential technology growth curves allow you to hide any number of early mistakes while also reaching massive audiences quickly. Exponential solutions can be the … Continue reading

Today’s flying through tomorrow’s eyes
Sir David Attenborough gave powerful testimony to a UK parliamentary committee recently, arguing that we need to reduce the amount of global air travel to cut our carbon footprint. The irony that he has spent his career flying the world … Continue reading

Opportunities beyond startups
Is it just me or has the world gone mad for startups and writing software? Don’t get me wrong, I am a big fan of startups and all that they bring to the economy. However, if you read the business … Continue reading

Email works too well
Everyone who regularly feels overwhelmed by their email would agree that there is a problem.  The hundreds of articles about the issue typically make the same assumption and are wrong. Writer after writer bemoans email as inefficient and an obstacle … Continue reading

The Internet was a mistake, now let’s fix it
Each generation over the last century has seen new technologies that become so embedded in their lives that its absence would be unimaginable. Early in the 20th century it was radio, which quickly become the entertainment of choice, then television, … Continue reading

© 2010-2019 Robert Hillard